Our Story

Sarah making fudgeSarah Tucker has been making gourmet fudge, hand-dipped buckeyes and other specialty candy since 2006. A mother of four children, Sarah has slowly expanded her business over the past eight years.

“When I first started I only had two flavors of fudge, now I make more than 20!” says Sarah. The fudge is still made by hand in small batches, using real butter and cream from a local grass-fed dairy.

Natural peanut butter is the key ingredient to the Peanut Butter Fudge which Sarah says is her top selling flavor. Chocolate and Maple Walnut are also very popular traditional flavors. If you like trying something new you might enjoy the key lime, salty caramel, or pumpkin pie.

Sarah also sells raw Ohio honey as she and her husband Trent have been beekeeping since 2011.

No matter what your sweet tooth is craving, Sarah’s Sweets is sure to please!